Sephora released their annual $10 Black Friday deals on Pinterest earlier this week (you can see their album here), but I only managed to catch them today. Happy Thanksgiving, procrastinators! If you’re trying to decide which items are a good deal, I have organized them from best to worst value.

Unlike previous years, all items have a calculable value, meaning there are no trashy brush sets that are probably worth $1.50 polluting the mix. Additionally, every set is worth more than the $10 purchase price.

Image source:ย

The Full List:

Formula X The Two in Juju & Voodoo
Juju and Voodoo (2 x 0.4 oz), retail value $12.00
Total Value: $12.00

Origins Task Maskers
0.5 oz Clear Improvement Active Charcoal Mask To Clear Pores, approximate retail value $3.68
0.5 oz Modern Friction Nature’s Gentle Dermabrasion, approximate retail value $4.70
0.5 oz Drink Up Intensive Overnight Mask, approximate retail value $3.68
Total Value: $12.06

Ole Henriksen The Clean Truth Cleansing Duo
African Red Tea Foaming Cleanser (1.5 fl oz), retail value $9.00
Clean Truth Cleansing Wipes (10 wipes), approximate retail value $5.00
Total Value: $14.00

Tocca A Touch Of Luxury Gift Set
(2 x 1 oz) Hand Cream in Giuliette and Stella, approximate retail value $8.00
(2 x 0.10 oz) Rollerballs in Giulietta and Stella, approximate retail value $8.00
Total Value: $16

Kat Von D Lip Love Set
0.04 oz Studded Kiss lipstick in Lolita, approximate retail value $8.40
0.10 oz Everlasting liquid lipstick in Berlin, approximate retail value $8.63
Total Value: $17.03

Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Collection
1 oz Perfect Hair Day Shampoo, approximate retail value $5.00
1 oz Perfect Hair Day Conditioner, approximate retail value $5.00
1 oz Perfect Hair Day 5-in-1 Styling, approximate retail value $7.50
Total Value: $17.50

Clean Rollerball Collection Trio
Warm Cotton, White Woods, and Fresh Laundry (3 X 0.17 fl oz), retail value $18
Total Value: $18

Josie Maran Argan Hand Healers
1 oz Whipped Argan Oil Intensive Hand Cream in Sweet Citrus, approximate retail value $9.29
20 x Bear Naked Nail Wipes in Lavender, retail value $9.00
Total Value: $18.29

Alterna Caviar Moisture Trio
Replenishing Moisture Shampoo (1.35 fl oz), approximate retail value $5.08
Replenishing Moisture Conditioner (1.35 fl oz), approximate retail value $5.08
Caviar CC Cream (1 fl oz), approximate retail value $10
Total Value: $20.16

Philosophy Purity Made Simple
Facial Cleanser (12 fl oz), approximate retail value $20.50
Total Value: $20.50

First Aid Beauty FAB Star Duo
2 oz Face Cleanser, retail value $9.50
2 oz Ultra Repair Cream, retail value $12.00
Total Value: $21.50

Boscia Pore-Purifying Duo
1 oz Luminizing Black Mask, approximate retail value $12.14
100 x Black Charcoal Blotting Linens, retail value $10.00
Total Value: $22.14

The Art of Shaving: The Four Elements of the Perfect Shave
Aftershave Balm (0.5 fl oz), approximate retail value $5.88
Pre-Shave Oil (0.5 fl oz), approximate retail value $8.00
Shaving Cream (1 oz), retail value $5.00
Trial Size Badger Shaving Brush, estimated retail value $5.00
Total Value: $23.88

Bliss Fabulous Foaming Face Wash
Face Wash in 6.7 oz, retail value $24
Total Value: $24

Formula X The Two in Chaotic & Hypnotize
Chaotic and Hypnotize (2 x 0.4 oz), retail value $24
Total Value: $24

Sephora Collection Precision Makes Perfect Mini Airbrush Set
2 X Sephora Collection Sponges, estimate retail value $24
Total Value: $24

Too Faced Primed For Sex
0.17 oz Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow Primer, approximate retail value $9.71
0.17 oz Better Than Sex Mascara,ย approximate retail value $14.48
Total Value: $24.19

Buxom Power Players
0.02 oz Mini Hold the Line Waterproof Eyeliner in Call Me, approximate retail value $8.50
0.33 oz Sculpted Lash Mascara in True Black, retail value $19.00
Total Value: $27.50

Smashbox Be Legendary Lipstick Duo
(2 x 0.7 oz) Travel-size Legendary lipsticks in Posy Pink, Fig, approximate retail value $28.00
Total Value: $28

BareMinerals the Incredibles Dynamic Eye & Lip Duo
0.1 oz BareMinerals READY eye shadow 2.0 in The Phenomenon, retail value $20
0.07 oz Marvelous Moxie lip gloss In Rebel, approximate retail value $8.40
Total value: $28.40

Tarte Magical Moments Deluxe Best Sellers Essentials Set
0.05 oz LipSurgence lip gloss, approximate retail value $3.52
0.15 oz Amazonian Clay 12-Hour blush in Magic, approximate retail value $19.50
0.13 oz Lights, Camera, Lashes mascara, retail value $10
Total Value: $33.02

Bite Beauty Lush Lip Trio Minis
(3 x 0.06 oz) Lush Fruit Lip Gloss in Strawberry, Currant, Rambutan, approximate retail value $36
Total Value: $36

Lab Shine (2 x 0.09 oz) in Shimmering Beige and Shimmering Indian Pink, retail value $38
Total Value: $38

NEST Fragrances Rollerball Trio
(3 X 0.6 oz) in Midnight Fleur, Dahlia & Vines, and Indigo, approximate retail value $68.82
Total Value: $68.82

My picks:

I think the Art of Shaving Kit is a great little inexpensive stocking stuffer, the Bare Minerals duo is lovely for anyone who wants to experience the awesomeness of their eyeshadow, and the Tarte kit is likely worth it, if only for the blush.

  1. campcomfort-02
    Kelly L-G

    You are back. Yay!!!!!

    Thanks for the price breakdown. I always snag a few of these black friday deals every year for myself and for stocking stuffers and it is nice to see how the value actually works out.

  2. Zoรซ

    great breakdown! I’m jealous the Ole wipes are only $5, they are double that in Canada, which works out to a dollar a wipe… and means the deal basically gives the cleanser for free.

  3. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Helpful! I have missed seeing this site updated, so thanks for coming back!

  4. campcomfort-40-40-03

    This convinced me to add the Nest set! Thanks for taking the time to do these calculations ๐Ÿ˜€

  5. RZDVS

    The Nest set is mislabeled. Sephora says that it’s 3 x .6 oz, but the image/box label shows that it’s .6 oz total (.2 oz each).

  6. Kailey

    I was able to snatch the Tarte set after he kept going out of stock – yay!

  7. campcomfort-40-40-03
    Erin G.

    Thanks, did not know about these deals. Have wanted to try Bite Beauty lipsticks, and the Tarte set looks wonderful. Glad to see your review, Robyn. Have missed readin’ ya.’

  8. Elizabeth

    you rule.

  9. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Why are the 2 Formula X sets different prices? They look the same (except for colors)

  10. Kimbre

    Wow! I had no idea there were this many! I went black friday shopping at the largest mall in my state and they only carried about half of these, would have loved that Bareminerals or Tarte set. ๐Ÿ™
    I still picked up a formula x duo for my mom and the shaving set for my boyfriend. ๐Ÿ™‚

  11. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Edit: The Nest fragrances are 0.2 fl oz each and 0.6 oz total on my box ๐Ÿ™‚

  12. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Your calculation should be correct, though, since it’s worth around $66 canadian.

  13. Lindsay Cockburn

    I love how you do these price breakdowns they are awesome!!

  14. campcomfort-40-40-03
    Anneke Vandenbroek

    Thank you for an awesome post and welcome back!

  15. campcomfort-40-40-03

    I’ve been pulling up old posts and all of the pictures are missing. (Like the eyeshadow primer analysis and the Lorac Mint Edition review.) Maybe it’s just me …

  16. Annamaria

    Welcome back! And thanks very much for the price breakdowns ๐Ÿ™‚

  17. Thach Nguyen

    Thanks for an awesome post! Welcome back

  18. Kat dela Cruz

    what’s wrong with your older photos? the pictures are unavailable


    Alexis Stewart

    I hate to say it, but I think it’s time to remove this blog from my bookmarks ๐Ÿ™

  19. LadyElectron

    I miss your blog updates! you are a hilarious writer, and in a world of nonsense beauty advice, your blog is awesome. Hope you come back soon ๐Ÿ™‚

  20. campcomfort-40-40-03

    I miss your posts! I really enjoy your blog and I know you are busy as the rest of us but your postings are delightful.

  21. campcomfort-40-40-03

    HI Robyn,

    To chime in with the others, I miss your posts. You were (are?) my favorite makeup blogger. No one else has the combination of honesty, snark and sharp observations. Come back?!?!?? Pretty please, but only if you feel like it.

    Happy 2015!

    a Loyal Lurking Reader who checks back often in hope

  22. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Robyn, wherever you went, I hope you are ok. I used to read all your posts but never commented, until now not seeing you post in so long. I hope all is well.

  23. Stacy AC

    Add me to the chorus, I miss your posts, and hope all is well and you are just happily busy.

  24. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Same boat. I’m not sure I’ve ever commented but I’m sad to not see any new posts. I hope you’re just busier with better things and hope you’re not unwell or anything.

  25. Kate (Lives Simply)

    Same song, another verse. ๐Ÿ™
    Hope you’re doing all right and I’d wish you’d at least give us some sort of update. I miss reading this. I canceled my Ipsy bag recently and I need someone to tell me what I’m (not) missing out on!

  26. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Another person hoping you are doing well, just miss reading your well written and hysterically funny/bitchy stuff so, so much.

  27. campcomfort-40-40-03

    Where’d you goooo (in the tone of the song)? Your sarcastically funny writing always amused me so hope you’re doing well and will be back with a new post soon ๐Ÿ™‚

  28. campcomfort-40-40-03

    It is SO hard to resist these Sephora deals, amiright?!